ID verification is the process of confirming the identity of a person or entity, usually to access a service, comply with a regulation, or prevent fraud. In Canada, ID verification is required in various contexts, such as opening a bank account, applying for a loan, registering for a government program, or verifying an online identity.
However, ID verification is not a simple or uniform process, as different service providers and regulators may have different methods and standards for ID verification, depending on their needs and risks. Moreover, ID verification is constantly evolving, as new technologies and innovations emerge to offer more convenient and secure solutions.
In this article, we will provide an overview of the methods, standards, and challenges of ID verification in Canada, and discuss some of the current and future trends and solutions for ID verification.
What are the Methods of ID Verification?
One of the main regulators for ID verification in Canada is the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC), which oversees the anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing regime. FINTRAC requires certain entities, such as banks, credit unions, money services businesses, securities dealers, and casinos, to verify the identity of their clients before providing them with financial services. FINTRAC also specifies the acceptable methods and documents for ID verification, which include:
1. Credit file method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to their credit file in Canada that has been in existence for at least six months. This method is convenient and fast, as it can be done online or over the phone, without requiring the person to present any physical documents. However, this method may not be suitable for people who do not have a credit history in Canada, such as newcomers, young adults, or low-income individuals.
2. Dual-process method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to two reliable and independent sources of information, such as a utility bill, a bank statement, or a government-issued document. This method is flexible and comprehensive, as it can use various types of documents that contain the person's name, address, and other relevant information. However, this method may be cumbersome and time-consuming, as it requires the person to provide two separate documents, which may not be readily available or up-to-date.
3. Government-issued photo ID method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to a valid and current government-issued document that has their name, date of birth, and photos. You could use one of these: a driver’s license, a passport, or a health card. This method is simple and reliable, as it can use a single document that is widely recognized and trusted.
However, this method may be restrictive and invasive, as it requires the person to present a physical document that may not be accessible or acceptable for some people, such as those who do not have a driver's license, a passport, or a health card, or those who do not want to share their photo or biometric information.
4. Single-process method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to a single source of information that is generated by a reliable and independent third party, such as a digital ID service, a verification service provider, or a government program. This method is innovative and efficient, as it can use a digital or electronic solution that can verify the person's identity in real-time, without requiring the person to provide any additional documents.
However, this method may be complex and risky, as it requires the person to trust and consent to a third party that may collect, store, and share their personal information, which may raise privacy and security concerns.
In addition to the methods regulated by FINTRAC, other methods of ID verification are not covered by FINTRAC but may be used by some service providers or regulators, depending on their needs and risks. These methods include:
a. Biometric method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to their unique physical or behavioural characteristics, such as their fingerprint, face, voice, or iris. This method is accurate and secure, as it can use a biometric feature that is difficult to forge or spoof.
However, this method may be costly and intrusive, as it requires the person to provide a biometric sample, which may not be comfortable or convenient for some people or may raise ethical or legal issues.
b. Behavioral method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to their online or offline activities, such as their browsing history, social media profiles, location data, or purchase patterns. This method is dynamic and adaptive, as it can use a variety of data sources that reflect the person's behaviour and preferences.
Further reading on Biometric: What is Biometric Verification
However, this method may be unreliable and unpredictable, as it may depend on the quality and availability of the data, or may be influenced by external factors, such as fraudsters, hackers, or malware.
c. Social media method:
Verifying the identity of a person by referring to their social media accounts, such as Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn. This method is popular and easy, as it can use a social media platform that the person already uses and trusts. However, this method may be superficial and deceptive, as it may rely on self-reported or unverified information, or may be manipulated by fake or stolen accounts, bots, or trolls
You might be interested in reading What is Digital Identity Verification
Standards and frameworks for ID verification
ID verification is not only a matter of methods, but also of standards and frameworks, which define the levels of assurance, quality, and interoperability for ID verification systems. Levels of assurance are the degree of confidence in the identity of a person or entity, which may vary depending on the context and the risk of the service or transaction.
For example, a higher level of assurance may be required for accessing a bank account or a health record, than for signing up for a newsletter or a game. Standards and frameworks provide the criteria and guidelines for determining and achieving the appropriate levels of assurance for ID verification systems, as well as ensuring their security, privacy, and compatibility across different sectors and jurisdictions.
One of the main standards and frameworks for ID verification in Canada is the Pan-Canadian Trust Framework (PCTF), which is a collaborative initiative by the Digital ID and Authentication Council of Canada (DIACC) and the Joint Councils of Canada (JCC). The PCTF defines the levels of assurance for digital identity systems, as well as the principles, processes, and criteria for verifying and authenticating digital identities in Canada.
The PCTF aims to facilitate interoperability, trust, and innovation for digital identity solutions across different sectors and jurisdictions in Canada, such as federal, provincial, territorial, and municipal governments, as well as private and non-profit organizations.
Another standard and framework for ID verification in Canada is the Identity Assurance Levels (IALs), which are part of the Government of Canada's Standard on Identity and Credential Assurance. The IALs describe the degree of confidence in the identity of a person or entity, based on the evidence and process used to verify their identity.
The IALs range from 1 to 3, with 1 being the lowest and 3 being the highest level of assurance. The IALs are used to determine the requirements and expectations for ID verification systems for government services and programs, as well as to align with international standards and best practices.
Implementing and harmonizing these standards and frameworks for ID verification in Canada is not without challenges, as it involves multiple stakeholders, regulations, technologies, and cultures.
Some of the benefits and challenges of these standards and frameworks are:
Some key benefits include:
- Enhance the quality and consistency of ID verification systems and services
- Increase the trust and confidence of users and providers of ID verification systems and services
- Enable the interoperability and compatibility of ID verification systems and services across different sectors and jurisdictions
- Foster the innovation and competitiveness of ID verification systems and services in the domestic and global markets
Key challenges include:
- Balance the needs and interests of different stakeholders, such as users, providers, regulators, and policymakers
- Comply with the existing and emerging regulations and laws, such as the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA), the Privacy Act, and the Anti-Money Laundering and Anti-Terrorist Financing Act
- Adapt to the changing and evolving technologies and innovations, such as blockchain, artificial intelligence, and biometrics
- Respect the diversity and inclusivity of different cultures and communities, such as Indigenous peoples, newcomers, and marginalized groups
Technologies and innovations for ID verification
As ID verification becomes more important and challenging in the digital age, there are various technologies and innovations that are being developed and deployed to offer more convenient and secure solutions for ID verification. These technologies and innovations aim to balance the trade-offs between convenience and efficiency, and trust and security, as well as to address the gaps and limitations of the existing methods and standards for ID verification.
Some of the examples of these technologies and innovations are:
A global AML compliance solution that integrates directly with independent and government-backed databases, offering ID verification and liveness checks to help digital finance apps and services comply with FINTRAC and confirm users' identities.
This solution leverages the credit file method and the government-issued photo ID method, as well as the biometric method, to provide a fast and easy ID verification process, while ensuring the accuracy and security of the user's identity and personal information.
2. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC) guidelines:
A set of recommendations and best practices for identification and authentication that aim to protect the privacy and personal information of individuals. These guidelines provide the principles and criteria for designing and implementing ID verification systems and services, such as minimizing the collection and retention of personal information, obtaining the consent and choice of individuals, and ensuring the transparency and accountability of ID verification systems and services.
These technologies and innovations offer new possibilities and opportunities for ID verification in Canada, but they also pose new challenges and risks, such as:
Possibilities and Opportunities:
- Improve the user experience and satisfaction of ID verification systems and services
- Reduce the cost and complexity of ID verification systems and services
- Enhance the security and reliability of ID verification systems and services
- Support the digital transformation and inclusion of ID verification systems and services
Challenges and Risks:
- Ensure the compatibility and interoperability of ID verification systems and services with the existing and emerging methods and standards
- Protect the privacy and security of personal information and identity data from unauthorized access, use, or disclosure
- Prevent and detect the fraud and abuse of ID verification systems and services by malicious actors or entities
- Address the ethical and social implications of ID verification systems and services for individuals and society
For more information read Online Identity verification
ID verification in Canada is a complex and evolving topic that involves multiple stakeholders, regulations, methods, and technologies. As more services and transactions move online, ID verification becomes more important and challenging. Therefore, it is essential for individuals, businesses, and governments to be aware of the current and emerging trends and solutions for ID verification in Canada, and to collaborate and innovate to create a more convenient, secure, and trustworthy ID verification ecosystem in Canada.
Youverify is a powerful and easy-to-use solution that allows you to verify any government-issued ID document in seconds. You can scan and authenticate your customers' IDs across our global document verification network, using artificial intelligence and machine learning. You can also customize the service to suit your specific needs and requirements.
With Youverify, you can:
• Improve your customer onboarding rate and experience
• Guard against onboarding fraudsters and money laundering
• Satisfy KYC compliance requirements and laws
• Verify the ID of anyone, anywhere globally
Don't let identity verification slow you down or expose you to risks. Join thousands of businesses that trust Youverify to verify their customers' identity online. Get started today by booking a demo or signing up today.